Haaretz Last update - 19:00 03/07/2008
By Jonathan Lis, Haaretz Correspondent
Several ultra-Orthodox groups rioted across Israel on Thursday in protest of the prospective autopsy of the body of Ziona Samin, who was murdered in her Ashkelon apartment a day before. Police detained eleven protesters for burning tires outside the National Institute of Forensic Medicine in Abu Kabir and trying to enter by force. In Jerusalem, masses of Haredi people barricaded Shivtey Israel Street, set fire to garbage bins and hurled stones at police cars. In Bnei Brak, rioting Haredim blocked Ezra Street.
Ziona Samin, a 65-year-old resident of Ashkelon, was murdered on Wednesday, apparently during a botched robbery. Her husband, Rabbi Yosef Samin, found her tied hand and foot, after apparently being severely battered. No suspects have been arrested.
jeudi 3 juillet 2008
Jerusalem terrorist's family told to take down mourners' tent
Haaretz Last update - 15:59 03/07/2008
By Jonathan Lis, Avi Issacharoff and Eli Ashkenazi, Haaretz Correspondents
The family of the East Jerusalem Palestinian who killed three people in an attack in the capital on Wednesday was told by Border Police on Thursday to remove a mourning tent it had set up to mark his death. Hussam Duwiyat, 30, from the East Jerusalem neighborhood of Zur Baher, was shot dead by security forces after stealing a bulldozer from the construction site where he was working and driving it into a bus and a number of cars on Jaffa Street in downtown Jerusalem. Three people were killed and dozens were wounded. The family lawyer said Wednesday that Duwiyat was not a terrorist and therefore the attack could not be described as terror. "This is a tragic event, the family and I send our condolences to the bereaved families and wish the wounded a speedy recovery,": said Shimon Kokush. "This was a young man who was jailed for rape. He was a junkie and drug-user." According to his family, Duwiyat had been employed as a bulldozer operator in recent years. He was not known to be involved in political activism in his community. However, the Battalions for the Liberation of the Galilee claimed responsibility for the attack, saying Duwiyat was recruited several months ago. Security sources said that the claim was likely false.
By Jonathan Lis, Avi Issacharoff and Eli Ashkenazi, Haaretz Correspondents
The family of the East Jerusalem Palestinian who killed three people in an attack in the capital on Wednesday was told by Border Police on Thursday to remove a mourning tent it had set up to mark his death. Hussam Duwiyat, 30, from the East Jerusalem neighborhood of Zur Baher, was shot dead by security forces after stealing a bulldozer from the construction site where he was working and driving it into a bus and a number of cars on Jaffa Street in downtown Jerusalem. Three people were killed and dozens were wounded. The family lawyer said Wednesday that Duwiyat was not a terrorist and therefore the attack could not be described as terror. "This is a tragic event, the family and I send our condolences to the bereaved families and wish the wounded a speedy recovery,": said Shimon Kokush. "This was a young man who was jailed for rape. He was a junkie and drug-user." According to his family, Duwiyat had been employed as a bulldozer operator in recent years. He was not known to be involved in political activism in his community. However, the Battalions for the Liberation of the Galilee claimed responsibility for the attack, saying Duwiyat was recruited several months ago. Security sources said that the claim was likely false.
Land day
Haaretz 3/7/2008 By Shuki Sadeh
Anyone who wants to fully understand the changes undergone by Israeli society since the establishment of the state, and even beforehand, need not visit a museum or watch some documentary series on television. It is sufficient to peruse the lawsuit that has been under deliberation for the past four years by the Petah Tikva District Court, which is due to hand down a verdict in the near future. The lawsuit is really the story of the Borochov neighborhood in Givatayim, which begins with a group of laborers agreeing to live together in a way that would benefit everyone, and ends with real-estate deals and a demand that the state return money to its citizens.
The six plaintiffs are descendants of the pioneering laborers who established the neighborhood. They claim that the Israel Lands Administration (ILA) is exploiting them ruthlessly, and has illegally charged them a total of NIS 7 million as a condition for approving construction on plots that they own - even though in the original contracts their families signed, there was no obligation to pay for building permits.
David Cohen, the lawyer representing the plaintiffs, explains that if the suit is upheld by the court, the residents of Borochov and similar, veteran neighborhoods in other parts of the country will be able to demand that the ILA return money they paid in the past, and could amount to as much as NIS 5 billion.
Borochov, the first such workers' neighborhood established in the country, was set up in 1922 by a group headed by David Schneiderman, who had arrived during the Second Aliyah (wave of immigration). Schneiderman, who tried to acquire land in various areas in the central region of the country (among others, near Bat Yam and Holon) was ultimately successful in locating 300 dunams (or 75 acres), which at the time were part of Ir Haganim - the Ramat Gan of today. Every one of the 22 settlers bought 2.5 dunams, for which they paid 300 liras upon signing the contract, and another 1,000 liras after three months. Later on, another 70 families joined the group, and they received smaller plots.
The lawsuit is full of stories from the pioneering days of the 1920s when the settlers worked as construction laborers in Tel Aviv, or as guards or even sanitation workers in British military camps, to be able to pay back the loans they had taken for buying the land. Even though they bought the plots using their own private savings, the settlers decided of their own initiative to transfer their property collectively to the Jewish National Fund (JNF), which at that time organized Jewish settlement in the Land of Israel. This voluntary transfer of privately purchased land was also evident in other parts of the country - in towns, moshavim and kibbutzim.
"Our parents were socialists. As they saw it, it was forbidden for them to own real estate and therefore they handed this land over to the JNF," explains Ran Aldema, who still lives in the neighborhood his father helped to establish. Because of this ideology, people who refused to hand over their plots for national ownership were not allowed to live in the neighborhood: "We are very careful when accepting members ... because we care about the basic precept of nationalization, which is not agreeable to everyone," the residents' committee of the Borochov neighborhood wrote in a letter to the JNF headquarters in 1924 - a letter that is quoted in the current lawsuit.
This ideology was superseded by more practical interests, such as real estate, and members of the second generation of residents started to make "combination" deals: Developers were allowed to build on the available plots and to sell some of the apartments in the buildings they completed, while handing over - in return - the remaining apartments to the land owners. When a new structure was erected, the owners were asked to pay higher monthly leasing fees in accordance with the size of the built-up area.
Starting in 1987, the rules of the game changed. Land owners who wanted to strike a combination deal were asked to pay a permit fee of between $100,000 and $300,000 to the ILA, which administered the JNF properties. The owners did not realize at first that people who had closed similar deals in the past were not required to pay such fees, and therefore did not object to the ILA's demand. Only later did they understand this and begin to examine the matter more closely.
The property owners discovered that for the last 20 years, the ILA had asked them to sign new leases, which included a clause stating that any new building on their property was conditional upon payment of a fee determined by the size of the land. In the lawsuit they submitted to the court, the owners claimed they did not know that the demand for paying a fee was not included in their original contracts. They were sure that the signature was merely a technical matter and did not imagine that the ILA would change the terms of the agreement for the worse.
Says Eli Goldstein, the son of the late Avraham Goldstein, who was one of the initiators of the lawsuit: "I assume that many other good people did not read the fine print. They were not naive, but did not foresee where this would lead. They did not imagine that someone would demand a payment during the construction work. The founders paid a full price for the land and donated it. But wonder of wonders! When it was time for realization, the ILA wanted a fee."
"The ILA is behaving aggressively and exploiting its power while disregarding its public obligations in a way that shows a lack of bona fide intentions and transparency," attorney Cohen wrote, summing up the plaintiffs' grievances. He also quoted remarks made at a conference of ILA legal advisers in November 1998: They stated that lessees with whom a new contract is signed should be able to enjoy the conditions of the original contract. "It is regrettable that the legal advisers did not take it a step further as could be expected of them - that is, to trace the lessees from whom permit fees were stolen in an illegal and indecent fashion, and to return the money stolen from them," the lawsuit says.
'Getting rich?'
The ILA claims, for its part, that the matter is no longer legally relevant because the new contracts were signed between 10 and 15 years ago. The plaintiffs counter that that claim is merely the ILA's way of shaking off responsibility, and say the real facts became clear to them only a few months before the the lawsuit was submitted. Cohen says he approached the attorney general and state prosecutor's office to look into the matter.
In any event, the ILA says everything was done in accordance with the law. It says that the plaintiffs are basing their claims on procedures which are in some cases no longer relevant, simply to avoid paying a large sum for building rights. "The permit fees that the plaintiffs were asked to pay by the ILA not only are firmly anchored in the law, but also no other outcome is reasonable and would merely mean getting rich illegally at the expense of the public," the state has said in response, on behalf of the ILA.
This claim infuriates the plaintiffs. Yonatan Mameluk, the son of one founder, is currently finalizing plans to tear down the old house in which his parents lived and to erect an eight-story residence instead. Mameluk's home is one of the only three remaining structures from the early years of Borochov. Another one is also about to be torn down, and a third was donated to the Givatayim municipality to serve as an artists' house.
Mameluk did not join in the lawsuit since he knew this would hold up his construction plans. However, he supports the plaintiffs. "What the ILA is saying is chutzpah of the first order," he says. "Did any of them come here in 1922 to settle? After all, my father didn't have a thing to eat. For years he would ride his donkey every day to his pharmacy in the Sharona neighborhood of Tel Aviv, and at the same time, he rented out a room in his house. Did we make a good deal? Not exactly. My father gave the JNF a gift and got nothing back. I am his heir and I have children, and I have the responsibility of taking care of them. The residents of the Borochov neighborhood won't get rich from these lands. After 'eating' from a piece of land for 85 years, you have earned your bread. Is that called getting rich?"
Many similar arguments can be found in the lawsuit, which also reflects the conceptual changes undergone by the descendants of the founders. The first few pages are full of descriptions of the pioneering efforts of the latter, but afterward the plaintiffs adapt themselves to the spirit of the times. In this way, the socialist pioneer of the 1920s turns into an enthusiastic supporter of individualism in the 21st century. "He doesn't owe a thing either to anyone else or to the authorities. He is not a righteous man, nor a pious one. He does what is required of him; he is an ordinary citizen" - thus the plaintiffs write in summary, quoting a ruling, in response to those who accuse them of growing rich at the expense of the state.
Yizhar Schneiderman, 96, is one of the only veteran residents who has a slightly different perspective. He was 10 when his father David helped spearhead the establishment of the neighborhood. He witnessed the meetings of residents where it was decided to hand over the land to the JNF. Today Schneiderman is upset about Borochov's metamorphosis into a real-estate gold mine, and has done something unusual, in contrast to others of his generation: He donated his family home to the municipality to be used as an arts center. Soon, after the other two remaining historic houses in the neighborhood are torn down, that structure will be the last relic of the early days.
"No one in the neighborhood thought it was right to do something to commemorate [my father's] name, so we decided to donate the house to the municipality. That is more important to us than what those who submitted the lawsuit want," Schneiderman says. "My father certainly did not want this neighborhood to turn into real estate. He was an idealist, but now everything is the opposite of what he wanted. If his vision were to be applied, many more homes would have been preserved for the good of the public and the Schneiderman house would not have been the only one." The younger Schneiderman eventually built a house on half of his father's plot, but received only three apartments in the deal and had to pay the monetary value of one of them to the ILA as a leasing fee. In view of this example, it is difficult to understand the claims of the plaintiffs. Even after paying the fees to the ILA, they would remain with apartments in desired neighborhoods in the center of the country, whose value the pioneers of the 1920s could not have ever imagined.
Anyone who wants to fully understand the changes undergone by Israeli society since the establishment of the state, and even beforehand, need not visit a museum or watch some documentary series on television. It is sufficient to peruse the lawsuit that has been under deliberation for the past four years by the Petah Tikva District Court, which is due to hand down a verdict in the near future. The lawsuit is really the story of the Borochov neighborhood in Givatayim, which begins with a group of laborers agreeing to live together in a way that would benefit everyone, and ends with real-estate deals and a demand that the state return money to its citizens.
The six plaintiffs are descendants of the pioneering laborers who established the neighborhood. They claim that the Israel Lands Administration (ILA) is exploiting them ruthlessly, and has illegally charged them a total of NIS 7 million as a condition for approving construction on plots that they own - even though in the original contracts their families signed, there was no obligation to pay for building permits.
David Cohen, the lawyer representing the plaintiffs, explains that if the suit is upheld by the court, the residents of Borochov and similar, veteran neighborhoods in other parts of the country will be able to demand that the ILA return money they paid in the past, and could amount to as much as NIS 5 billion.
Borochov, the first such workers' neighborhood established in the country, was set up in 1922 by a group headed by David Schneiderman, who had arrived during the Second Aliyah (wave of immigration). Schneiderman, who tried to acquire land in various areas in the central region of the country (among others, near Bat Yam and Holon) was ultimately successful in locating 300 dunams (or 75 acres), which at the time were part of Ir Haganim - the Ramat Gan of today. Every one of the 22 settlers bought 2.5 dunams, for which they paid 300 liras upon signing the contract, and another 1,000 liras after three months. Later on, another 70 families joined the group, and they received smaller plots.
The lawsuit is full of stories from the pioneering days of the 1920s when the settlers worked as construction laborers in Tel Aviv, or as guards or even sanitation workers in British military camps, to be able to pay back the loans they had taken for buying the land. Even though they bought the plots using their own private savings, the settlers decided of their own initiative to transfer their property collectively to the Jewish National Fund (JNF), which at that time organized Jewish settlement in the Land of Israel. This voluntary transfer of privately purchased land was also evident in other parts of the country - in towns, moshavim and kibbutzim.
"Our parents were socialists. As they saw it, it was forbidden for them to own real estate and therefore they handed this land over to the JNF," explains Ran Aldema, who still lives in the neighborhood his father helped to establish. Because of this ideology, people who refused to hand over their plots for national ownership were not allowed to live in the neighborhood: "We are very careful when accepting members ... because we care about the basic precept of nationalization, which is not agreeable to everyone," the residents' committee of the Borochov neighborhood wrote in a letter to the JNF headquarters in 1924 - a letter that is quoted in the current lawsuit.
This ideology was superseded by more practical interests, such as real estate, and members of the second generation of residents started to make "combination" deals: Developers were allowed to build on the available plots and to sell some of the apartments in the buildings they completed, while handing over - in return - the remaining apartments to the land owners. When a new structure was erected, the owners were asked to pay higher monthly leasing fees in accordance with the size of the built-up area.
Starting in 1987, the rules of the game changed. Land owners who wanted to strike a combination deal were asked to pay a permit fee of between $100,000 and $300,000 to the ILA, which administered the JNF properties. The owners did not realize at first that people who had closed similar deals in the past were not required to pay such fees, and therefore did not object to the ILA's demand. Only later did they understand this and begin to examine the matter more closely.
The property owners discovered that for the last 20 years, the ILA had asked them to sign new leases, which included a clause stating that any new building on their property was conditional upon payment of a fee determined by the size of the land. In the lawsuit they submitted to the court, the owners claimed they did not know that the demand for paying a fee was not included in their original contracts. They were sure that the signature was merely a technical matter and did not imagine that the ILA would change the terms of the agreement for the worse.
Says Eli Goldstein, the son of the late Avraham Goldstein, who was one of the initiators of the lawsuit: "I assume that many other good people did not read the fine print. They were not naive, but did not foresee where this would lead. They did not imagine that someone would demand a payment during the construction work. The founders paid a full price for the land and donated it. But wonder of wonders! When it was time for realization, the ILA wanted a fee."
"The ILA is behaving aggressively and exploiting its power while disregarding its public obligations in a way that shows a lack of bona fide intentions and transparency," attorney Cohen wrote, summing up the plaintiffs' grievances. He also quoted remarks made at a conference of ILA legal advisers in November 1998: They stated that lessees with whom a new contract is signed should be able to enjoy the conditions of the original contract. "It is regrettable that the legal advisers did not take it a step further as could be expected of them - that is, to trace the lessees from whom permit fees were stolen in an illegal and indecent fashion, and to return the money stolen from them," the lawsuit says.
'Getting rich?'
The ILA claims, for its part, that the matter is no longer legally relevant because the new contracts were signed between 10 and 15 years ago. The plaintiffs counter that that claim is merely the ILA's way of shaking off responsibility, and say the real facts became clear to them only a few months before the the lawsuit was submitted. Cohen says he approached the attorney general and state prosecutor's office to look into the matter.
In any event, the ILA says everything was done in accordance with the law. It says that the plaintiffs are basing their claims on procedures which are in some cases no longer relevant, simply to avoid paying a large sum for building rights. "The permit fees that the plaintiffs were asked to pay by the ILA not only are firmly anchored in the law, but also no other outcome is reasonable and would merely mean getting rich illegally at the expense of the public," the state has said in response, on behalf of the ILA.
This claim infuriates the plaintiffs. Yonatan Mameluk, the son of one founder, is currently finalizing plans to tear down the old house in which his parents lived and to erect an eight-story residence instead. Mameluk's home is one of the only three remaining structures from the early years of Borochov. Another one is also about to be torn down, and a third was donated to the Givatayim municipality to serve as an artists' house.
Mameluk did not join in the lawsuit since he knew this would hold up his construction plans. However, he supports the plaintiffs. "What the ILA is saying is chutzpah of the first order," he says. "Did any of them come here in 1922 to settle? After all, my father didn't have a thing to eat. For years he would ride his donkey every day to his pharmacy in the Sharona neighborhood of Tel Aviv, and at the same time, he rented out a room in his house. Did we make a good deal? Not exactly. My father gave the JNF a gift and got nothing back. I am his heir and I have children, and I have the responsibility of taking care of them. The residents of the Borochov neighborhood won't get rich from these lands. After 'eating' from a piece of land for 85 years, you have earned your bread. Is that called getting rich?"
Many similar arguments can be found in the lawsuit, which also reflects the conceptual changes undergone by the descendants of the founders. The first few pages are full of descriptions of the pioneering efforts of the latter, but afterward the plaintiffs adapt themselves to the spirit of the times. In this way, the socialist pioneer of the 1920s turns into an enthusiastic supporter of individualism in the 21st century. "He doesn't owe a thing either to anyone else or to the authorities. He is not a righteous man, nor a pious one. He does what is required of him; he is an ordinary citizen" - thus the plaintiffs write in summary, quoting a ruling, in response to those who accuse them of growing rich at the expense of the state.
Yizhar Schneiderman, 96, is one of the only veteran residents who has a slightly different perspective. He was 10 when his father David helped spearhead the establishment of the neighborhood. He witnessed the meetings of residents where it was decided to hand over the land to the JNF. Today Schneiderman is upset about Borochov's metamorphosis into a real-estate gold mine, and has done something unusual, in contrast to others of his generation: He donated his family home to the municipality to be used as an arts center. Soon, after the other two remaining historic houses in the neighborhood are torn down, that structure will be the last relic of the early days.
"No one in the neighborhood thought it was right to do something to commemorate [my father's] name, so we decided to donate the house to the municipality. That is more important to us than what those who submitted the lawsuit want," Schneiderman says. "My father certainly did not want this neighborhood to turn into real estate. He was an idealist, but now everything is the opposite of what he wanted. If his vision were to be applied, many more homes would have been preserved for the good of the public and the Schneiderman house would not have been the only one." The younger Schneiderman eventually built a house on half of his father's plot, but received only three apartments in the deal and had to pay the monetary value of one of them to the ILA as a leasing fee. In view of this example, it is difficult to understand the claims of the plaintiffs. Even after paying the fees to the ILA, they would remain with apartments in desired neighborhoods in the center of the country, whose value the pioneers of the 1920s could not have ever imagined.
mercredi 2 juillet 2008
'Girls, go to the back'
'Girls, go to the back'
Rabbinical transportation committee calls on young women to ride buses in halachic manner, meaning to congregate in back of bus, even in those buses not deemed 'kosher', in which driver won't open back door
Neta Sela
Yedioth Ahranoth Published: 07.02.08, 07:29
In a brochure distributed recently among the girls of the Beit Yaakov congregation, the Rabbinical Committee of Transportation asked the young women to preserve "halachic riding" during every bus ride, and not only on the buses defined as "kosher".
A kosher bus is one that allows the boarding of men through the front door, while women board using the back door. "Unfortunately there are still buses driving through the ultra-Orthodox neighborhoods that have not received permission from the Transportation Ministry to open the back door for the female travelers," the rabbis explained in the handout.
They therefore requested that "these bus lines also be converted to kosher lines, by having the female travelers congregate in the back of the bus after paying." The committee hopes this move "will cause the transportation companies to come to their senses, hurry up and make these lines kosher, and permit the opening of the back door in them as well."
In their letter to the young women of Beit Yaakov the rabbis stressed that those girls who are strict about their own modesty should see it as a privilege, and asked them to advise their friends to sit in the back of the bus. "Thanks to the preservation of the modesty and sanctity limitations we will gain the inspiration of the Divine Presence of creation, an abundance of wealth and happiness and everything good," the rabbis blessed the girls.
Next goal: Train wreck
The rabbis are also preparing for their battle against Jerusalem's new light train, which, in their opinion, holds various dangers in its wake. In an ad published by the committee, the rabbis explain that once the train is completed, the Transportation Ministry plans to cancel many of the ultra-Orthodox neighborhoods' kosher bus lines, thus forcing the inhabitants to make use of the new train.
The rabbis stated that "the light train is not compatible with the needs of the ultra-Orthodox public, material or spiritual, and the intention to coerce the ultra-Orthodox public into using the light train constitutes a grave spiritual danger."
The rabbis added that "the Transportation Ministry intends to alter the courses of the buses that serve the general public and reroute them through Geula neighborhood, thus completely ruining the spiritual identity of the neighborhood."
The rabbis called on those who can to assist in the matter, as these plans "completely ignore the needs of the ultra-Orthodox public, and will cause the collapse of the ultra-Orthodox transportation layout in Jerusalem, which required much labor to achieve."
Rabbinical transportation committee calls on young women to ride buses in halachic manner, meaning to congregate in back of bus, even in those buses not deemed 'kosher', in which driver won't open back door
Neta Sela
Yedioth Ahranoth Published: 07.02.08, 07:29
In a brochure distributed recently among the girls of the Beit Yaakov congregation, the Rabbinical Committee of Transportation asked the young women to preserve "halachic riding" during every bus ride, and not only on the buses defined as "kosher".
A kosher bus is one that allows the boarding of men through the front door, while women board using the back door. "Unfortunately there are still buses driving through the ultra-Orthodox neighborhoods that have not received permission from the Transportation Ministry to open the back door for the female travelers," the rabbis explained in the handout.
They therefore requested that "these bus lines also be converted to kosher lines, by having the female travelers congregate in the back of the bus after paying." The committee hopes this move "will cause the transportation companies to come to their senses, hurry up and make these lines kosher, and permit the opening of the back door in them as well."
In their letter to the young women of Beit Yaakov the rabbis stressed that those girls who are strict about their own modesty should see it as a privilege, and asked them to advise their friends to sit in the back of the bus. "Thanks to the preservation of the modesty and sanctity limitations we will gain the inspiration of the Divine Presence of creation, an abundance of wealth and happiness and everything good," the rabbis blessed the girls.
Next goal: Train wreck
The rabbis are also preparing for their battle against Jerusalem's new light train, which, in their opinion, holds various dangers in its wake. In an ad published by the committee, the rabbis explain that once the train is completed, the Transportation Ministry plans to cancel many of the ultra-Orthodox neighborhoods' kosher bus lines, thus forcing the inhabitants to make use of the new train.
The rabbis stated that "the light train is not compatible with the needs of the ultra-Orthodox public, material or spiritual, and the intention to coerce the ultra-Orthodox public into using the light train constitutes a grave spiritual danger."
The rabbis added that "the Transportation Ministry intends to alter the courses of the buses that serve the general public and reroute them through Geula neighborhood, thus completely ruining the spiritual identity of the neighborhood."
The rabbis called on those who can to assist in the matter, as these plans "completely ignore the needs of the ultra-Orthodox public, and will cause the collapse of the ultra-Orthodox transportation layout in Jerusalem, which required much labor to achieve."
mardi 1 juillet 2008
Palestinians who approach Gaza fence will be shot, says IDF
Haaretz Last update - 10:05 01/07/2008
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent
Israel has informed Hamas it will fire "warning shots" at Palestinians who enter an area west of the Gaza Strip border fence, extending for several hundred meters. Egyptian officials told Hamas of the new procedure, which is expected to raise tensions between the two sides. Israel's representative in truce talks, Amos Gilad, told Egyptian mediators of the decision to declare the area west of the border a "special security zone" and to prevent Palestinians from entering it. The Egyptians informed Hamas, which objects to the plan.
Several incidents have occurred near the fence since a cease-fire came into effect on June 19. Earlier this week the United Nations sources reported eight cease-fire violations by Israel. Most of these violations apparently consisted of Israeli troops firing at people who approached the fence. The information relies mainly on Palestinian accounts.
Israel is interested in maintaining the security zone for fear that Palestinian terror groups will use the truce to plant explosives on the Palestinian side of the fence. This would prepare them if fighting resumes. In the past, explosives aimed at Israel Defense Forces vehicles on the Israeli side have been planted in this area. Israel also fears that Hamas might build a line of fortifications along the fence as a basis for further attacks, as Hezbollah did in Lebanon between Israel's pullout from South Lebanon in 2000 and the Second Lebanon War in 2006.
However, preventing people from approaching the fence will block Palestinian farmers' access to their lands. Farmers have been unable to reach their fields for years because of the fighting along the border. The IDF suspects that some of the farmers are sent by terror organizations to plant bombs or observe Israeli troops.
Throughout the second intifada Israel declared areas along the fence as "security zones." Soldiers were instructed to fire warning shots at people approaching the fence, and for certain periods were allowed to shoot even at unarmed people. These instructions met resistance in the army, with senior officers saying civilians were being killed. The IDF believes that Hamas has recently been taking firmer action to curb other Palestinian factions' attacks against Israel. IDF sources told Haaretz that Hamas' leadership in Gaza apparently wants to maintain the truce and is trying to enforce its authority on the smaller factions. At the beginning of the week Israel opened the border crossings that had been closed last Thursday after Qassam rockets were fired at the Western Negev
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent
Israel has informed Hamas it will fire "warning shots" at Palestinians who enter an area west of the Gaza Strip border fence, extending for several hundred meters. Egyptian officials told Hamas of the new procedure, which is expected to raise tensions between the two sides. Israel's representative in truce talks, Amos Gilad, told Egyptian mediators of the decision to declare the area west of the border a "special security zone" and to prevent Palestinians from entering it. The Egyptians informed Hamas, which objects to the plan.
Several incidents have occurred near the fence since a cease-fire came into effect on June 19. Earlier this week the United Nations sources reported eight cease-fire violations by Israel. Most of these violations apparently consisted of Israeli troops firing at people who approached the fence. The information relies mainly on Palestinian accounts.
Israel is interested in maintaining the security zone for fear that Palestinian terror groups will use the truce to plant explosives on the Palestinian side of the fence. This would prepare them if fighting resumes. In the past, explosives aimed at Israel Defense Forces vehicles on the Israeli side have been planted in this area. Israel also fears that Hamas might build a line of fortifications along the fence as a basis for further attacks, as Hezbollah did in Lebanon between Israel's pullout from South Lebanon in 2000 and the Second Lebanon War in 2006.
However, preventing people from approaching the fence will block Palestinian farmers' access to their lands. Farmers have been unable to reach their fields for years because of the fighting along the border. The IDF suspects that some of the farmers are sent by terror organizations to plant bombs or observe Israeli troops.
Throughout the second intifada Israel declared areas along the fence as "security zones." Soldiers were instructed to fire warning shots at people approaching the fence, and for certain periods were allowed to shoot even at unarmed people. These instructions met resistance in the army, with senior officers saying civilians were being killed. The IDF believes that Hamas has recently been taking firmer action to curb other Palestinian factions' attacks against Israel. IDF sources told Haaretz that Hamas' leadership in Gaza apparently wants to maintain the truce and is trying to enforce its authority on the smaller factions. At the beginning of the week Israel opened the border crossings that had been closed last Thursday after Qassam rockets were fired at the Western Negev
Libellés :
freedom-of-movement,
gaza,
israeli-army,
violence
New law stipulates: Territorial withdrawal only by referendum
Haaretz Last update - 08:31 01/07/2008
By Shahar Ilan and Eli Ashkenazi, Haaretz Correspondents
The Knesset approved on Monday the referendum law, which mandates a national referendum or a two thirds Knesset majority prior to a withdrawal from any territory under Israeli territory. The law was approved in its first reading by a majority of 65 MKs to 18. The vote came as indirect peace talks were underway between Israel and Syria, revolving around the Syrian demand that Israel return the Golan Heights, which it captured from Syria during the 1967 Six-Day War, in return for peace. A third round of talks was to begin this week. Earlier Monday, the "Golan Lobby" convened at the Knesset ahead of the vote. The meeting was attended by Deputy Prime Minister and Trade Minister Eli Yishai (Shas), who said that the law is a positive and important measure, though his party generally opposes holding referendums.
"I think that talk about [pulling out of the Golan] Heights cause great damage to the residents," Yishai said. "Anything we can do to help is a blessing and is required and therefore we will support the law." An existing law already mandates a referendum before ceding any territory under Israeli sovereignty, but it also states that this requirement will not apply until a Basic Law detailing the procedures for holding a referendum is passed. The current law eliminated the need to enact a Basic Law. Instead, it requires that territorial concessions be approved by a national referendum or general elections or a majority of 80 Knesset members.
Golan Lobby Chairman MK Yisrael Katz said that it was extremely important that the law was approved, in order to make it clear that attempts to hand over the Golan will be followed by the tedious procedure of a referendum. "There is an important message here, especially while negotiations are underway," Katz said. Opposition Chairman Benjamin Netanyahu said the "in Western countries, giving up land is impossibly difficult, and in tiny little Israel, governments can relinquish land with unbearable ease. This is something that must be rectified, and the law can do that." MK Yuval Steinitz (Likud) said that negotiations over the Golan Heights were a crime. "Giving up the Golan would be a national disaster that the Zionist endeavor will not recover from," he said. Deputy Knesset Speaker Yuli Edelstein (Likud) said "the Knesset needs to learn from its own history - this law sends a clear message that the decision will be approved by the people, without outside considerations, tricks or political bribes." MK David Tal (Kadima), the chairman of the special committee that prepared the law, said Sunday that "if the referendum law is approved by less than 65 MKs, I will view it as a personal failure."
By Shahar Ilan and Eli Ashkenazi, Haaretz Correspondents
The Knesset approved on Monday the referendum law, which mandates a national referendum or a two thirds Knesset majority prior to a withdrawal from any territory under Israeli territory. The law was approved in its first reading by a majority of 65 MKs to 18. The vote came as indirect peace talks were underway between Israel and Syria, revolving around the Syrian demand that Israel return the Golan Heights, which it captured from Syria during the 1967 Six-Day War, in return for peace. A third round of talks was to begin this week. Earlier Monday, the "Golan Lobby" convened at the Knesset ahead of the vote. The meeting was attended by Deputy Prime Minister and Trade Minister Eli Yishai (Shas), who said that the law is a positive and important measure, though his party generally opposes holding referendums.
"I think that talk about [pulling out of the Golan] Heights cause great damage to the residents," Yishai said. "Anything we can do to help is a blessing and is required and therefore we will support the law." An existing law already mandates a referendum before ceding any territory under Israeli sovereignty, but it also states that this requirement will not apply until a Basic Law detailing the procedures for holding a referendum is passed. The current law eliminated the need to enact a Basic Law. Instead, it requires that territorial concessions be approved by a national referendum or general elections or a majority of 80 Knesset members.
Golan Lobby Chairman MK Yisrael Katz said that it was extremely important that the law was approved, in order to make it clear that attempts to hand over the Golan will be followed by the tedious procedure of a referendum. "There is an important message here, especially while negotiations are underway," Katz said. Opposition Chairman Benjamin Netanyahu said the "in Western countries, giving up land is impossibly difficult, and in tiny little Israel, governments can relinquish land with unbearable ease. This is something that must be rectified, and the law can do that." MK Yuval Steinitz (Likud) said that negotiations over the Golan Heights were a crime. "Giving up the Golan would be a national disaster that the Zionist endeavor will not recover from," he said. Deputy Knesset Speaker Yuli Edelstein (Likud) said "the Knesset needs to learn from its own history - this law sends a clear message that the decision will be approved by the people, without outside considerations, tricks or political bribes." MK David Tal (Kadima), the chairman of the special committee that prepared the law, said Sunday that "if the referendum law is approved by less than 65 MKs, I will view it as a personal failure."
Libellés :
golan,
land,
occupied-territories,
syria
vendredi 27 juin 2008
UN: Israel violated truce 7 times in one week
UN: Israel violated truce 7 times in one week
UN records 7 incidents of IDF soldiers attempting to drive Palestinian farmers away from border fence by shooting at them. Only one offence marked against Palestinians for firing on Sderot; report does not include most recent rocket fire
Roi Mandel
Yedioth Ahranoth Published: 06.27.08, 00:31
Since it went into effect last week, at least eight violations of the new ceasefire agreement with Hamas and the Palestinian factions have been recorded, a UN source told Ynet on Thursday. According to the source, seven violations were committed by the IDF, while the Palestinians are responsible for just one.
However the UN report does not include the Qassam fire launched towards the Negev during the day. "It is important that both sides honor the ceasefire, in order for it to be the first constructive step towards a wider and more extensive peace process between the sides," the source said.
Most of the offences committed by the IDF include shots fired by soldiers at Palestinian farmers attempting to reach their land near the border security fence. According to the UN, on June 20 an IDF patrol shot at Palestinian farmers near the fence east of Rafah. The soldiers fired for ten minutes in order to drive the farmers away, but no injuries were reported.
During the evening of the same day a similar incident was recorded, in which IDF forces shot at Palestinian farmers near the Maghazi refugee camp. Soldiers reportedly fired for five minutes, and no injuries were reported. An hour later soldiers fired towards fisherman near the northern Gaza Strip town of Beit Lahiya in an attempt to drive them away.
Early on June 21 Navy forces opened fire in the same area, and later the same morning forces fired towards Palestinians near the Maghazi refugee camp. No injuries were reported in either case.
70-year old Jamil al-Gahoul was injured from IDF fire two days later, when an army patrol opened fire on a group of Palestinians reportedly gathering wood near Beit Lahiya at 7 am.
Only one Palestinian offence
The first violation committed by the Palestinians was recorded a day later, on June 24, when Islamic Jihad fired three rockets at Sderot from the northern Gaza Strip town of Beit Hanoun.
On Wednesday morning IDF forces opened fire towards Palestinian farmers near the southern Gaza Strip town of Khan Younis. An 82-year old man was seriously injured from the fire, which lasted a few minutes.
Regarding the accusations against Israel the IDF stated that no attacks had been carried out in the Gaza Strip during the past few days, but that some incidents had occurred in which IDF soldiers had carried out operations.
Israel and Hamas have accused each other of violating the ceasefire agreement. Following the rocket fire at Sderot, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said that the fire constitutes a blatant violation of the truce. Defense Minister Ehud Barak decided that the Gaza border crossings would remain closed following the fire, causing Hamas to accuse Israel of infringement of the agreement.
Hanan Greenberg contributed to this report
UN records 7 incidents of IDF soldiers attempting to drive Palestinian farmers away from border fence by shooting at them. Only one offence marked against Palestinians for firing on Sderot; report does not include most recent rocket fire
Roi Mandel
Yedioth Ahranoth Published: 06.27.08, 00:31
Since it went into effect last week, at least eight violations of the new ceasefire agreement with Hamas and the Palestinian factions have been recorded, a UN source told Ynet on Thursday. According to the source, seven violations were committed by the IDF, while the Palestinians are responsible for just one.
However the UN report does not include the Qassam fire launched towards the Negev during the day. "It is important that both sides honor the ceasefire, in order for it to be the first constructive step towards a wider and more extensive peace process between the sides," the source said.
Most of the offences committed by the IDF include shots fired by soldiers at Palestinian farmers attempting to reach their land near the border security fence. According to the UN, on June 20 an IDF patrol shot at Palestinian farmers near the fence east of Rafah. The soldiers fired for ten minutes in order to drive the farmers away, but no injuries were reported.
During the evening of the same day a similar incident was recorded, in which IDF forces shot at Palestinian farmers near the Maghazi refugee camp. Soldiers reportedly fired for five minutes, and no injuries were reported. An hour later soldiers fired towards fisherman near the northern Gaza Strip town of Beit Lahiya in an attempt to drive them away.
Early on June 21 Navy forces opened fire in the same area, and later the same morning forces fired towards Palestinians near the Maghazi refugee camp. No injuries were reported in either case.
70-year old Jamil al-Gahoul was injured from IDF fire two days later, when an army patrol opened fire on a group of Palestinians reportedly gathering wood near Beit Lahiya at 7 am.
Only one Palestinian offence
The first violation committed by the Palestinians was recorded a day later, on June 24, when Islamic Jihad fired three rockets at Sderot from the northern Gaza Strip town of Beit Hanoun.
On Wednesday morning IDF forces opened fire towards Palestinian farmers near the southern Gaza Strip town of Khan Younis. An 82-year old man was seriously injured from the fire, which lasted a few minutes.
Regarding the accusations against Israel the IDF stated that no attacks had been carried out in the Gaza Strip during the past few days, but that some incidents had occurred in which IDF soldiers had carried out operations.
Israel and Hamas have accused each other of violating the ceasefire agreement. Following the rocket fire at Sderot, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said that the fire constitutes a blatant violation of the truce. Defense Minister Ehud Barak decided that the Gaza border crossings would remain closed following the fire, causing Hamas to accuse Israel of infringement of the agreement.
Hanan Greenberg contributed to this report
Libellés :
israeli-army,
occupied-territories,
UN
jeudi 26 juin 2008
Israeli Arab teaches Palestinians about the Holocaust
Haaretz Last update - 15:36 26/06/2008
By Yoav Stern, Haaretz Correspondent
On the way to the Hawara checkpoint, near the West Bank city of Nablus, Khaled Ksab Mahamid says: "You remember that you are American, yes? How is your accent in English?" Mahamid, whose family originates from a destroyed Arab village near what is now Megiddo, is the founder and director of a private Holocaust museum in Nazareth. We are on our way to the Balata refugee camp, where he is scheduled to give a lecture. The tension at the checkpoint is rising.
In general, Palestinians and Arabs try not to talk about the Holocaust. The distance between solidarity with the Jewish people and solidarity with the Jewish state is short, and is not usually up for discussion, especially in a refugee camp. Mahamid has a unique perspective on this issue. He argues that the Palestinian people paid the price for the Holocaust during their Nakba - Arabic for "catastrophe" or the day of Israel's independence. Mahamid says that Palestinians are still paying for the Holocaust, and will continue to do so, if it does not learn what happened to the Jews.
He has lectured in the Nablus area in the past, but this is his first time in Balata. He does not know exactly what to expect. The organizers of the lecture welcome him at the entrance to the camp, shake his hand. The first stop: memorial for the fallen. Mahamid mumbles the fataha, the opening chapter of the Koran, within the palms of his hands extended upward like an open book. After the memorial, we go down to one of the alleyways in the camp. It is exactly like in the movies ? the narrow alleyways of a refugee camp. A dozen or so residents gather next to a clubhouse - which also serves as the headquarters of Al-Alqsa Martyrs Brigade commander and Fatah parliament member, Jamal Tirawi, who was arrested by Israeli forces last year.
Mahamid begins his lecture with the claim that the Zionist movement has failed, in a big way. "Most Jews did not come to Palestine. Also today, there are eight million [Jews] in the world that are not here. Where are they?" The crowd listens quietly. One of the guests gets up to serve juice and cookies. When he stands, the gun in his belt is evident.
Mahamid raises his hands and warns that the Palestinians must not be like Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. This, he says, plays into the hands of the Zionists. Palestinians must remember the Jews' weak points. "Know your enemy," he says. He does not exactly tell what happened to the Jews during the Holocaust; he hints at it. He shows pictures of Jewish prisoners in the death camps and says Palestinians must use "understand what the other thinks, not deny it." "The Israelis believe in this, the Germans and the French believe in this. We also need to adopt this," he says. Addressing the crowd, he continues: "You, who live in Balata, could you tell somebody this is a lie?"
Mahamid insists that the Palestinians have to end the violent struggle against Israel, as given that they have lost six million of their people, the deaths of 25 in a terrorist attack will not deter them. Another person attending the lecture, of local origin, becomes angry. There is no logic in making the occupation a five-star occupation, he says. He is also against Mahamid's claim that the Zionist movement has failed. "If one Jew comes, if they took my father's orchard in Jaffa, it has not failed. Have you not read the Protocols of the Elders of Zion? They sit in a tent but want to control the entire world." As we leave the refugee camp and head back toward Hawara checkpoint, the tension eases. The journalists are already chatting in Hebrew with the guests. At the checkpoint, Mahamid pulls out his ID for the woman soldier. With his ID, he always carries a picture of a Jewish child from the Holocaust - why not shame the soldiers a little? When the woman soldier expresses amazement, he produces more pictures of Jews from the Holocaust and tells her that he just gave a lecture on the subject at Balata.
By Yoav Stern, Haaretz Correspondent
On the way to the Hawara checkpoint, near the West Bank city of Nablus, Khaled Ksab Mahamid says: "You remember that you are American, yes? How is your accent in English?" Mahamid, whose family originates from a destroyed Arab village near what is now Megiddo, is the founder and director of a private Holocaust museum in Nazareth. We are on our way to the Balata refugee camp, where he is scheduled to give a lecture. The tension at the checkpoint is rising.
In general, Palestinians and Arabs try not to talk about the Holocaust. The distance between solidarity with the Jewish people and solidarity with the Jewish state is short, and is not usually up for discussion, especially in a refugee camp. Mahamid has a unique perspective on this issue. He argues that the Palestinian people paid the price for the Holocaust during their Nakba - Arabic for "catastrophe" or the day of Israel's independence. Mahamid says that Palestinians are still paying for the Holocaust, and will continue to do so, if it does not learn what happened to the Jews.
He has lectured in the Nablus area in the past, but this is his first time in Balata. He does not know exactly what to expect. The organizers of the lecture welcome him at the entrance to the camp, shake his hand. The first stop: memorial for the fallen. Mahamid mumbles the fataha, the opening chapter of the Koran, within the palms of his hands extended upward like an open book. After the memorial, we go down to one of the alleyways in the camp. It is exactly like in the movies ? the narrow alleyways of a refugee camp. A dozen or so residents gather next to a clubhouse - which also serves as the headquarters of Al-Alqsa Martyrs Brigade commander and Fatah parliament member, Jamal Tirawi, who was arrested by Israeli forces last year.
Mahamid begins his lecture with the claim that the Zionist movement has failed, in a big way. "Most Jews did not come to Palestine. Also today, there are eight million [Jews] in the world that are not here. Where are they?" The crowd listens quietly. One of the guests gets up to serve juice and cookies. When he stands, the gun in his belt is evident.
Mahamid raises his hands and warns that the Palestinians must not be like Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. This, he says, plays into the hands of the Zionists. Palestinians must remember the Jews' weak points. "Know your enemy," he says. He does not exactly tell what happened to the Jews during the Holocaust; he hints at it. He shows pictures of Jewish prisoners in the death camps and says Palestinians must use "understand what the other thinks, not deny it." "The Israelis believe in this, the Germans and the French believe in this. We also need to adopt this," he says. Addressing the crowd, he continues: "You, who live in Balata, could you tell somebody this is a lie?"
Mahamid insists that the Palestinians have to end the violent struggle against Israel, as given that they have lost six million of their people, the deaths of 25 in a terrorist attack will not deter them. Another person attending the lecture, of local origin, becomes angry. There is no logic in making the occupation a five-star occupation, he says. He is also against Mahamid's claim that the Zionist movement has failed. "If one Jew comes, if they took my father's orchard in Jaffa, it has not failed. Have you not read the Protocols of the Elders of Zion? They sit in a tent but want to control the entire world." As we leave the refugee camp and head back toward Hawara checkpoint, the tension eases. The journalists are already chatting in Hebrew with the guests. At the checkpoint, Mahamid pulls out his ID for the woman soldier. With his ID, he always carries a picture of a Jewish child from the Holocaust - why not shame the soldiers a little? When the woman soldier expresses amazement, he produces more pictures of Jews from the Holocaust and tells her that he just gave a lecture on the subject at Balata.
'Modesty police' patrols bridge ceremony
'Modesty police' patrols bridge ceremony
Dancers scheduled to appear in opening ceremony of new Chords Bridge in Jerusalem undergo emergency wardrobe change after ultra-Orthodox elements deem original outfits immodest, threaten mass protest
Neta Sela
Yedioth Ahranoth Published: 06.26.08, 10:56
A cover-up: The dancers hired to perform at Wednesday inauguration ceremony of Jerusalem's new Chords Bridge had to undergo a last-minute wardrobe change, after ultra-Orthodox elements deemed their costume "too revealing," and threatened to stage a mass protest at the ceremony.
Jerusalem Mayor Uri Lupolianski was reportedly under significant pressure to cancel the performance altogether, but eventually, a compromised was reached: The dancers were dressed in long outfits – complete with headdress – which rendered their figures unrecognizable. The performance was also cut from three segments to one.
Yaniv Hoffman, the company's manager, slammed the decision: "The parents and the girls were stunned and we're completely thrown. This company has been performing in every official city event for the past 20 years and this is the first time anything like this has happened. These are 13 to 16-year-old dancers. This is art, it's not like they're go-go dancers."
The secular residents of Jerusalem, added Hoffman, should do something now, before it is too late: "This isn't just the company's fight. The public has to wake up. These are dark days for all of us. It saddens me to see the depths our capital has sunk to."
City Councilman Saar Netanel called the decision "scandalous", adding it serves as an example to the city's "backwards leadership."
"Miraculously, the Gay Pride Parade held in the city on Thursday will represent the exact opposite… The parade belongs not only to the proud members of the capital's gay community, but to the company's dancers as well, and to the rest of the free public," added Netanel.
The Jerusalem Municipality denied any involvement in the decision to change the dancers' outfits.
Dancers scheduled to appear in opening ceremony of new Chords Bridge in Jerusalem undergo emergency wardrobe change after ultra-Orthodox elements deem original outfits immodest, threaten mass protest
Neta Sela
Yedioth Ahranoth Published: 06.26.08, 10:56
A cover-up: The dancers hired to perform at Wednesday inauguration ceremony of Jerusalem's new Chords Bridge had to undergo a last-minute wardrobe change, after ultra-Orthodox elements deemed their costume "too revealing," and threatened to stage a mass protest at the ceremony.
Jerusalem Mayor Uri Lupolianski was reportedly under significant pressure to cancel the performance altogether, but eventually, a compromised was reached: The dancers were dressed in long outfits – complete with headdress – which rendered their figures unrecognizable. The performance was also cut from three segments to one.
Yaniv Hoffman, the company's manager, slammed the decision: "The parents and the girls were stunned and we're completely thrown. This company has been performing in every official city event for the past 20 years and this is the first time anything like this has happened. These are 13 to 16-year-old dancers. This is art, it's not like they're go-go dancers."
The secular residents of Jerusalem, added Hoffman, should do something now, before it is too late: "This isn't just the company's fight. The public has to wake up. These are dark days for all of us. It saddens me to see the depths our capital has sunk to."
City Councilman Saar Netanel called the decision "scandalous", adding it serves as an example to the city's "backwards leadership."
"Miraculously, the Gay Pride Parade held in the city on Thursday will represent the exact opposite… The parade belongs not only to the proud members of the capital's gay community, but to the company's dancers as well, and to the rest of the free public," added Netanel.
The Jerusalem Municipality denied any involvement in the decision to change the dancers' outfits.
lundi 23 juin 2008
Panel slams Israel's handling of Holocaust survivors
Haaretz Last update - 03:14 23/06/2008
By Anshel Pfeffer
A state committee appointed to review successive governments' aid to Holocaust survivors recommended, in a report submitted yesterday, that the government substantially increase stipends paid to 43,000 survivors, making them comparable to 75 percent of the reparations payment survivors receive from the German government. The committee, headed by retired Supreme Court justice Dalia Dorner, concluded that Israel was under a moral, as well as legal, obligation to take care of those survivors who could not sue Germany directly after the reparations agreement was signed in 1952, and said the state had evaded its responsibility for decades.
Speaking at a press conference yesterday, Dorner said that by forfeiting reparations on behalf of those survivors, the state had created a situation in which "whoever did not choose to live in Israel received much greater compensation." By the committee's calculations, the value of monies and goods Israel received under the reparations law now computes to NIS 61.5 billion, whereas over the years survivors received payouts and medical services valued only at NIS 38 billion in real terms. Some 43,000 survivors who came to Israel only after the beginning of 1953 were barred from suing Germany, accrued damages of between NIS 1.3 million and NIS 2.2 million per survivor (depending on an individual's disability ranking).
The committee found that the government ignored a High Court of Justice ruling from 12 years ago that ordered parity between the Israeli and German stipends. However, Dorner said the committee took into account the government's budget constraints in recommending that survivors be compensated retroactively only from the beginning of this year, and receive payments equal to only 75 percent of the German pension. This means that 43,000 survivors should soon see their monthly allowance increase by hundreds of shekels (depending on disability ranking), and would also be eligible for a one-time grant of up to NIS 3,900.
On submitting their report yesterday to Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, the committee members demanded that he take steps to begin implementing their recommendations within three weeks. Olmert ordered that a committee, headed by the director general of his office, Raanan Dinur, work to implement the report's conclusions. Implementing the report will cost an estimated NIS 262 million this year, but that sum is expected to go down in upcoming years, as some survivors die off.
About two-thirds of Holocaust survivors have already died without benefit of improved living conditions, Dorner said yesterday, and half of those still alive today will pass away over the next decade. The committee criticized the conduct of the Finance Ministry office in charge of handling survivors, saying it made things difficult for survivors and treated them in a "random" and sometimes even "arbitrary " manner. A committee member, Prof. Zvi Eisikovitz, said at the press conference that "survivors have to stop being treated like suspects." The committee recommended setting up a sub-unit in the office whose job would be to approach survivors, instead of waiting for them to apply, and help them to maximize their rights. Another recommendation is for the government to establish a special welfare service for Holocaust survivors.
By Anshel Pfeffer
A state committee appointed to review successive governments' aid to Holocaust survivors recommended, in a report submitted yesterday, that the government substantially increase stipends paid to 43,000 survivors, making them comparable to 75 percent of the reparations payment survivors receive from the German government. The committee, headed by retired Supreme Court justice Dalia Dorner, concluded that Israel was under a moral, as well as legal, obligation to take care of those survivors who could not sue Germany directly after the reparations agreement was signed in 1952, and said the state had evaded its responsibility for decades.
Speaking at a press conference yesterday, Dorner said that by forfeiting reparations on behalf of those survivors, the state had created a situation in which "whoever did not choose to live in Israel received much greater compensation." By the committee's calculations, the value of monies and goods Israel received under the reparations law now computes to NIS 61.5 billion, whereas over the years survivors received payouts and medical services valued only at NIS 38 billion in real terms. Some 43,000 survivors who came to Israel only after the beginning of 1953 were barred from suing Germany, accrued damages of between NIS 1.3 million and NIS 2.2 million per survivor (depending on an individual's disability ranking).
The committee found that the government ignored a High Court of Justice ruling from 12 years ago that ordered parity between the Israeli and German stipends. However, Dorner said the committee took into account the government's budget constraints in recommending that survivors be compensated retroactively only from the beginning of this year, and receive payments equal to only 75 percent of the German pension. This means that 43,000 survivors should soon see their monthly allowance increase by hundreds of shekels (depending on disability ranking), and would also be eligible for a one-time grant of up to NIS 3,900.
On submitting their report yesterday to Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, the committee members demanded that he take steps to begin implementing their recommendations within three weeks. Olmert ordered that a committee, headed by the director general of his office, Raanan Dinur, work to implement the report's conclusions. Implementing the report will cost an estimated NIS 262 million this year, but that sum is expected to go down in upcoming years, as some survivors die off.
About two-thirds of Holocaust survivors have already died without benefit of improved living conditions, Dorner said yesterday, and half of those still alive today will pass away over the next decade. The committee criticized the conduct of the Finance Ministry office in charge of handling survivors, saying it made things difficult for survivors and treated them in a "random" and sometimes even "arbitrary " manner. A committee member, Prof. Zvi Eisikovitz, said at the press conference that "survivors have to stop being treated like suspects." The committee recommended setting up a sub-unit in the office whose job would be to approach survivors, instead of waiting for them to apply, and help them to maximize their rights. Another recommendation is for the government to establish a special welfare service for Holocaust survivors.
Poll: 77% of Israeli Arabs would rather live in Israel than in any other country in the world
Haaretz Last update - 16:53 23/06/2008
By Bradley Burston, Haaretz Correspondent
A recent opinion poll conducted by Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government found that 77 percent of Israeli Arabs would rather live in Israel than in any other country in the world. The survey of 1,721 Israelis, both Arab and Jewish, also showed that 73 percent of the Jews and 94 percent of the Arabs want Israel to "be a society in which Arab and Jewish citizens have mutual respect and equal opportunities." The Kennedy School said in a statement that the poll produced a number of results it termed surprising, pointing to a higher level of co-existence than might have been anticipated.
The research comes at a period of simmering tensions in some sectors of the Arab-Jewish divide within Israel. The release of the poll coincided with celebrations, accompanied by widespread Israeli Arab boycotts, of the 60th anniversary of the state's declaration of independence. Israeli Arab MKs cited widespread discrimination as the cause of the boycotts. At the same time, MK Limor Livnat (Likud) proposed that the Knesset remove Arabic from its list of the country's official primary languages.
However, Professor Todd Pittinsky, research director of the Kennedy School's Center for Public Leadership and lead researcher for the poll, said that the results pointed to a contrary phenomenon. Much media coverage focuses on the divisions between Jewish and Arab citizens in Israel, and not enough on the sincere and concerted efforts to coexist peacefully, Pittinsky said in a statement. According to the poll, 68 percent of Jewish citizens support teaching conversational Arabic in Jewish schools to help bring Arab and Jewish citizens together. The data also showded that more than two-thirds of Israeli Jews (69 percdent) said they believed that contributing to co-existence was a personal responsibility.
"Every day, innovative experiments in coexistence are going on," Pittinsky said. "People on the ground in Israel are running community centers that enable cultural exchanges; in bilingual schools?like the Hand in Hand network of schools - young Jewish and Arab children become culturally conversant with each other. These deserve as much attention as rockets and roadblocks. They should be nurtured, studied, funded, and reported in the media. Ultimately the most successful efforts should be launched on a wider scale."
The study, conducted in Hebrew and Arabic with the assistance of University of Haifa researchers, was funded by the Alan B. Slifka foundation, which has sponsored a number of coexistence projects. "This report supports what we have long suspected?unity among Israel?s Jewish and Arab communities is not only attainable, but there is great public support for it," philanthropist Slifka said. "The critical next step is for Israeli policy makers to bring about the structural changes that the Jewish and Arab publics support, to reshape the educational, income, residential, and other divides that undermine national unity."
By Bradley Burston, Haaretz Correspondent
A recent opinion poll conducted by Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government found that 77 percent of Israeli Arabs would rather live in Israel than in any other country in the world. The survey of 1,721 Israelis, both Arab and Jewish, also showed that 73 percent of the Jews and 94 percent of the Arabs want Israel to "be a society in which Arab and Jewish citizens have mutual respect and equal opportunities." The Kennedy School said in a statement that the poll produced a number of results it termed surprising, pointing to a higher level of co-existence than might have been anticipated.
The research comes at a period of simmering tensions in some sectors of the Arab-Jewish divide within Israel. The release of the poll coincided with celebrations, accompanied by widespread Israeli Arab boycotts, of the 60th anniversary of the state's declaration of independence. Israeli Arab MKs cited widespread discrimination as the cause of the boycotts. At the same time, MK Limor Livnat (Likud) proposed that the Knesset remove Arabic from its list of the country's official primary languages.
However, Professor Todd Pittinsky, research director of the Kennedy School's Center for Public Leadership and lead researcher for the poll, said that the results pointed to a contrary phenomenon. Much media coverage focuses on the divisions between Jewish and Arab citizens in Israel, and not enough on the sincere and concerted efforts to coexist peacefully, Pittinsky said in a statement. According to the poll, 68 percent of Jewish citizens support teaching conversational Arabic in Jewish schools to help bring Arab and Jewish citizens together. The data also showded that more than two-thirds of Israeli Jews (69 percdent) said they believed that contributing to co-existence was a personal responsibility.
"Every day, innovative experiments in coexistence are going on," Pittinsky said. "People on the ground in Israel are running community centers that enable cultural exchanges; in bilingual schools?like the Hand in Hand network of schools - young Jewish and Arab children become culturally conversant with each other. These deserve as much attention as rockets and roadblocks. They should be nurtured, studied, funded, and reported in the media. Ultimately the most successful efforts should be launched on a wider scale."
The study, conducted in Hebrew and Arabic with the assistance of University of Haifa researchers, was funded by the Alan B. Slifka foundation, which has sponsored a number of coexistence projects. "This report supports what we have long suspected?unity among Israel?s Jewish and Arab communities is not only attainable, but there is great public support for it," philanthropist Slifka said. "The critical next step is for Israeli policy makers to bring about the structural changes that the Jewish and Arab publics support, to reshape the educational, income, residential, and other divides that undermine national unity."
Bridge over stormy council - uproar over work performed on Shabbat
Bridge over stormy council
Building of new Chords Bridge in capital's entrance enrages Jerusalem councilmen as final stages of construction reportedly performed on Shabbat with mayor's approval. Contractor says incident was 'severe mistake,' denies Lupolianski had prior knowledge
Ronen Medzini
Yedioth Ahranoth Published: 06.23.08, 08:21
Strident chords: The construction of the new Chords Bridge leading into Jerusalem caused controversy in the city's municipal meeting Sunday, as several of City Hall's coalition members were enraged by reports suggesting several construction workers were spotted working on Shabbat.
The bridge, which is supposed to carry the city's new light train, has been under construction for the past three years. Jerusalem's coalition members believed the some of the work was done on Shabbat in order to finish it in time for Wednesday's inauguration ceremony.
"Not only is it not worth it, it offended many people's emotions, both religious and secular," Shmuel Yitzhaky, a Shas Jerusalem councilman told Ynet Monday.
"The fact that the Jerusalem municipality sponsored this work is very grave. For what? For a ceremony? There is no reason what so ever to finish it of Shabbat."
Under construction. The bridge (Photo: Sasson Tiram)
Yitzhaky also said he believed the work was sanctioned by Jerusalem Mayor Uri Lupolianski. The people in City Hall, he added, "are only concerned with their jobs and don't care about the coalition."
Yehoshua Mor Yosef, spokesman for the Moria Company, which was tasked with the bridge's construction and who issued a statement on behalf of both Moria and the Jerusalem Municipality, said that the company sees the incident as severe.
Moreover, "The company has decided to immediately relieve the project's foreman and the construction's supervisor of their duties in order to make sure this kind of mishap never happens again."
Mor Yosef further denied Lupolianski's involvement in the decision to finish the project on Shabbat: "The mayor had no knowledge about any activities which were carried out in violation of the building contract, which clearly stipulates that, no work should be done on the bridge on Shabbat. The construction workers involved were Arab's hired by a sub-contractor, who sent them to the site against orders."
The inauguration ceremony itself has encountered some objections in the city council: Nir Bareket, who heads the municipality's opposition, slammed the costs – estimated as NIS 2 million (approximately $600,000) as unnecessarily extravagant.
"These public funds should have found their way to more important causes, such as schools and the city's beautification," he said.
Building of new Chords Bridge in capital's entrance enrages Jerusalem councilmen as final stages of construction reportedly performed on Shabbat with mayor's approval. Contractor says incident was 'severe mistake,' denies Lupolianski had prior knowledge
Ronen Medzini
Yedioth Ahranoth Published: 06.23.08, 08:21
Strident chords: The construction of the new Chords Bridge leading into Jerusalem caused controversy in the city's municipal meeting Sunday, as several of City Hall's coalition members were enraged by reports suggesting several construction workers were spotted working on Shabbat.
The bridge, which is supposed to carry the city's new light train, has been under construction for the past three years. Jerusalem's coalition members believed the some of the work was done on Shabbat in order to finish it in time for Wednesday's inauguration ceremony.
"Not only is it not worth it, it offended many people's emotions, both religious and secular," Shmuel Yitzhaky, a Shas Jerusalem councilman told Ynet Monday.
"The fact that the Jerusalem municipality sponsored this work is very grave. For what? For a ceremony? There is no reason what so ever to finish it of Shabbat."
Under construction. The bridge (Photo: Sasson Tiram)
Yitzhaky also said he believed the work was sanctioned by Jerusalem Mayor Uri Lupolianski. The people in City Hall, he added, "are only concerned with their jobs and don't care about the coalition."
Yehoshua Mor Yosef, spokesman for the Moria Company, which was tasked with the bridge's construction and who issued a statement on behalf of both Moria and the Jerusalem Municipality, said that the company sees the incident as severe.
Moreover, "The company has decided to immediately relieve the project's foreman and the construction's supervisor of their duties in order to make sure this kind of mishap never happens again."
Mor Yosef further denied Lupolianski's involvement in the decision to finish the project on Shabbat: "The mayor had no knowledge about any activities which were carried out in violation of the building contract, which clearly stipulates that, no work should be done on the bridge on Shabbat. The construction workers involved were Arab's hired by a sub-contractor, who sent them to the site against orders."
The inauguration ceremony itself has encountered some objections in the city council: Nir Bareket, who heads the municipality's opposition, slammed the costs – estimated as NIS 2 million (approximately $600,000) as unnecessarily extravagant.
"These public funds should have found their way to more important causes, such as schools and the city's beautification," he said.
samedi 21 juin 2008
UNICEF severs ties with Israeli mogul over settlement building
Haaretz Last update - 11:24 21/06/2008
By Reuters
The UN children's fund UNICEF has severed ties with an Israeli billionaire and financial backer due to his suspected involvement in building settlements in the West Bank, UNICEF said on Friday. Lev Leviev, a real estate and diamond mogul who is one of the richest men in Israel, has supported UNICEF with direct contributions and indirectly by sponsoring at least one UNICEF fund-raiser. He is chairman of Africa Israel Investments, a conglomerate whose units include Danya Cebus, which the Arab rights advocacy group Adalah-NY charges has carried out settlement construction, considered illegal by the United Nations.
UNICEF decided to review its relationship with Leviev after a campaign by Adalah-NY and found "at least a reasonable grounds for suspecting" that Leviev companies were building settlements in Palestinian territory, a UNICEF official said. "I can confirm that UNICEF has advised Adalah in New York that it will not be entering into any partnerships or accepting financial contributions from Lev Leviev or his corporate people," Chris de Bono, a senior adviser to the executive director of UNICEF, told Reuters. "We are aware of the controversy surrounding Mr. Leviev because of his reported involvement in construction work in the occupied Palestinian territory," de Bono said, adding that it was UNICEF's policy to have partners who were "as non-controversial as possible." UNICEF could not say how much Leviev had donated as an individual. In his only known partnership with UNICEF, Leviev last year donated jewelry to a fashion event in France that benefited the French national committee for UNICEF, de Bono said. Representatives of Leviev's jewelry and real estate businesses were not immediately available to comment on Friday, in part because of religious observances after dark in Israel.
By Reuters
The UN children's fund UNICEF has severed ties with an Israeli billionaire and financial backer due to his suspected involvement in building settlements in the West Bank, UNICEF said on Friday. Lev Leviev, a real estate and diamond mogul who is one of the richest men in Israel, has supported UNICEF with direct contributions and indirectly by sponsoring at least one UNICEF fund-raiser. He is chairman of Africa Israel Investments, a conglomerate whose units include Danya Cebus, which the Arab rights advocacy group Adalah-NY charges has carried out settlement construction, considered illegal by the United Nations.
UNICEF decided to review its relationship with Leviev after a campaign by Adalah-NY and found "at least a reasonable grounds for suspecting" that Leviev companies were building settlements in Palestinian territory, a UNICEF official said. "I can confirm that UNICEF has advised Adalah in New York that it will not be entering into any partnerships or accepting financial contributions from Lev Leviev or his corporate people," Chris de Bono, a senior adviser to the executive director of UNICEF, told Reuters. "We are aware of the controversy surrounding Mr. Leviev because of his reported involvement in construction work in the occupied Palestinian territory," de Bono said, adding that it was UNICEF's policy to have partners who were "as non-controversial as possible." UNICEF could not say how much Leviev had donated as an individual. In his only known partnership with UNICEF, Leviev last year donated jewelry to a fashion event in France that benefited the French national committee for UNICEF, de Bono said. Representatives of Leviev's jewelry and real estate businesses were not immediately available to comment on Friday, in part because of religious observances after dark in Israel.
Will secret conversion course go on?
Jun. 19, 2008
Matthew Wagner , THE JERUSALEM POST
Shevach Mofet High School on south Tel Aviv's Rehov Hamasger is a living example of what many Israelis perceive to be a danger to the Jewish state's religious-cultural unity.
Perhaps no other high school better embodies the effect of the absorption of hundreds of thousands of non-Jews from the former Soviet Union as part of the waves of immigration in the 1980s and 1990s.
Of the elite math and science school's 1,600-strong student body, hundreds are gentiles by Orthodox Jewish standards.
True, the vast majority of Israelis might not consider themselves Orthodox. But most would grudgingly say Orthodoxy is the most legitimate expression of Judaism.
As a result, the gentile students at Shevach Mofet, part of group of about 300,000 non-Jewish immigrants from the FSU, have to cope with the gnawing feeling that they are not full-fledged citizens of a state that defines itself as both democratic and Jewish - especially the females, since matrilineal descent determines whether the next generation is Jewish or not.
So it comes as no surprise that it was at Shevach Mofet that the Immigrant Absorption Ministry, together with the Education Ministry, the IDF and a few maverick Orthodox rabbis launched a pilot program to instill non-Jewish students with the requisite knowledge and religious experience to prepare for conversion to Judaism.
"The demand came from the students," Avigdor Leviatan, head of the Absorption Ministry's Conversion Division, said on Thursday.
"School psychologists were confronted with dozens of cases of students who were concerned about their lack of Jewishness and how that affected their feeling of belonging to the Jewish people.
"So we decided to set up a curriculum that would prepare high school students for an Orthodox conversion. The first group of seven or eight girls will appear before the conversion court in the coming month."
Participants devote six hours a week for a year to the studies and take part in Shabbatot during which they are immersed in a Orthodox environment on religious kibbutzim.
In the coming year, the program will be expanded to schools in five cities and will include 300 students, Leviatan said.
The program, which was started nearly two years ago, was kept secret to prevent the Ashkenazi haredi establishment from attacking it. Chief Sephardi Rabbi Shlomo Amar, who is in charge of conversions, defers to the Ashkenazi haredi rabbis.
In the past Amar has backed down to haredi pressure. Many Orthodox rabbis, especially in haredi circles, oppose accepting as converts teenage girls enrolled in a totally secular, coed high school and living in an irreligious household.
An integral part of conversion to Judaism is embracing an Orthodox lifestyle, including maintaining a kosher diet, adhering to the restrictions against work on Shabbat and accepting sexual abstinence until marriage.
Conservative-minded rabbis, with a predisposition to being suspect of the purity of potential converts' intentions, doubt young women who are in a totally secular environment can faithfully embrace Orthodoxy.
Perhaps out of concern that the Shevach Mofet program will encounter stiff rabbinic opposition, more moderate rabbis within the National Conversion Authority, the body approved by the Chief Rabbinate to perform conversions, are denying any knowledge of and trying to downplay the issue.
For instance, the deputy head of the Conversion Authority, Rabbi Moshe Klein, told The Jerusalem Post that he was not familiar with the conversion program at Shevach Mofet.
"I know nothing about the program," Klein said. "I don't know how many students are learning in the program. I don't know what the educational content is and I have not set up a panel of judges to convert anyone."
Klein's comments contradicted statements made by Leviatan, who said that both Klein and Rabbi Haim Druckman, the outgoing head of the authority, knew all about the program and wholeheartedly supported it. "They are afraid of hurting the chances of its success," said Leviatan. "That's why they do not want to comment right now."
Leviatan said that several conversion judges have already agreed to cooperate with the program.
One of the judges named by Leviatan is a well respected rabbi who is not considered particularly lenient. The judge denied that he was involved.
Rabbi Sefi Sherman, who heads Tel Aviv's Beit Midrash Tair, an educational program that brings together secular and religious teenagers, is the educational director of the Shevach Mofet initiative.
Beit Midrash Tair provided young, dynamic rabbis who could teach the young women at Shevach Mofet in an interesting, nonthreatening atmosphere.
Sherman, who is also the principal of a high school in Tel Aviv, declined to comment.
Leviatan said that he agreed to an interview with the Post only after the story was revealed by Tel Aviv, a local weekly. Tel Aviv's breaking of the story also led to coverage on Israel Radio.
"Media exposure will only hurt the chances that this program will succeed," Leviatan said.
Matthew Wagner , THE JERUSALEM POST
Shevach Mofet High School on south Tel Aviv's Rehov Hamasger is a living example of what many Israelis perceive to be a danger to the Jewish state's religious-cultural unity.
Perhaps no other high school better embodies the effect of the absorption of hundreds of thousands of non-Jews from the former Soviet Union as part of the waves of immigration in the 1980s and 1990s.
Of the elite math and science school's 1,600-strong student body, hundreds are gentiles by Orthodox Jewish standards.
True, the vast majority of Israelis might not consider themselves Orthodox. But most would grudgingly say Orthodoxy is the most legitimate expression of Judaism.
As a result, the gentile students at Shevach Mofet, part of group of about 300,000 non-Jewish immigrants from the FSU, have to cope with the gnawing feeling that they are not full-fledged citizens of a state that defines itself as both democratic and Jewish - especially the females, since matrilineal descent determines whether the next generation is Jewish or not.
So it comes as no surprise that it was at Shevach Mofet that the Immigrant Absorption Ministry, together with the Education Ministry, the IDF and a few maverick Orthodox rabbis launched a pilot program to instill non-Jewish students with the requisite knowledge and religious experience to prepare for conversion to Judaism.
"The demand came from the students," Avigdor Leviatan, head of the Absorption Ministry's Conversion Division, said on Thursday.
"School psychologists were confronted with dozens of cases of students who were concerned about their lack of Jewishness and how that affected their feeling of belonging to the Jewish people.
"So we decided to set up a curriculum that would prepare high school students for an Orthodox conversion. The first group of seven or eight girls will appear before the conversion court in the coming month."
Participants devote six hours a week for a year to the studies and take part in Shabbatot during which they are immersed in a Orthodox environment on religious kibbutzim.
In the coming year, the program will be expanded to schools in five cities and will include 300 students, Leviatan said.
The program, which was started nearly two years ago, was kept secret to prevent the Ashkenazi haredi establishment from attacking it. Chief Sephardi Rabbi Shlomo Amar, who is in charge of conversions, defers to the Ashkenazi haredi rabbis.
In the past Amar has backed down to haredi pressure. Many Orthodox rabbis, especially in haredi circles, oppose accepting as converts teenage girls enrolled in a totally secular, coed high school and living in an irreligious household.
An integral part of conversion to Judaism is embracing an Orthodox lifestyle, including maintaining a kosher diet, adhering to the restrictions against work on Shabbat and accepting sexual abstinence until marriage.
Conservative-minded rabbis, with a predisposition to being suspect of the purity of potential converts' intentions, doubt young women who are in a totally secular environment can faithfully embrace Orthodoxy.
Perhaps out of concern that the Shevach Mofet program will encounter stiff rabbinic opposition, more moderate rabbis within the National Conversion Authority, the body approved by the Chief Rabbinate to perform conversions, are denying any knowledge of and trying to downplay the issue.
For instance, the deputy head of the Conversion Authority, Rabbi Moshe Klein, told The Jerusalem Post that he was not familiar with the conversion program at Shevach Mofet.
"I know nothing about the program," Klein said. "I don't know how many students are learning in the program. I don't know what the educational content is and I have not set up a panel of judges to convert anyone."
Klein's comments contradicted statements made by Leviatan, who said that both Klein and Rabbi Haim Druckman, the outgoing head of the authority, knew all about the program and wholeheartedly supported it. "They are afraid of hurting the chances of its success," said Leviatan. "That's why they do not want to comment right now."
Leviatan said that several conversion judges have already agreed to cooperate with the program.
One of the judges named by Leviatan is a well respected rabbi who is not considered particularly lenient. The judge denied that he was involved.
Rabbi Sefi Sherman, who heads Tel Aviv's Beit Midrash Tair, an educational program that brings together secular and religious teenagers, is the educational director of the Shevach Mofet initiative.
Beit Midrash Tair provided young, dynamic rabbis who could teach the young women at Shevach Mofet in an interesting, nonthreatening atmosphere.
Sherman, who is also the principal of a high school in Tel Aviv, declined to comment.
Leviatan said that he agreed to an interview with the Post only after the story was revealed by Tel Aviv, a local weekly. Tel Aviv's breaking of the story also led to coverage on Israel Radio.
"Media exposure will only hurt the chances that this program will succeed," Leviatan said.
Libellés :
jewish-immigration,
judaism,
zionism
vendredi 20 juin 2008
"Religious freedom now" - but only for Jewish converts
By Reuven Hammer
Haaretz 20/6/2008
At last the problems of conversion in Israel have begun to receive the attention and press coverage they deserve. Not since the Hanaton conversions in 1995, when our Masorti (Conservative) rabbinical court converted adopted children that the Rabbinate had refused to convert because their adoptive parents were not Orthodox, has so much publicity and public discussion been focused on the way in which Israel's official rabbinical establishment treats potential and actual converts. That earlier crisis led to the formation of the Neeman Commission, which ended its work without even issuing a report - because of the opposition of the Chief Rabbinate to any cooperation with other groups. But it also resulted in a 2002 Supreme Court decision requiring the state to register Masorti converts in Israel as Jews. That was a step forward, but no more than that. It took the high beit din's disgraceful treatment of Rabbi Chaim Druckman earlier this spring, and the retroactive voiding of thousands of his conversions, regardless of the consequences for the converts, their partners and their children, to once again arouse public concern about a problem that has been with us for years.
I am hardly the first to respond to the decision of the Rabbinate's highest court not to recognize conversions carried out by the state-appointed conversion administration headed by Druckman, and with the exception of the occasional ultra-Orthodox writer, all have been critical of the Rabbinate's actions. Depending on each individual writer's religious orientation, there have been calls for the replacement of the court's current judges, all of whom are Haredim, by more moderate religious-Zionist rabbis; for the Israeli Supreme Court to overturn the decisions of the rabbinical court; for the state to fully recognize conversions performed by Masorti and Reform rabbis in Israel; and for the creation of secular conversion, so that non-Jews can join the Jewish people without undergoing any religious process whatsoever.
Many of these suggestions are valuable. It would certainly be a step forward if Haredi rabbis of the Rabbinate and its high court were replaced by Zionist ones. This is, after all, a Zionist state, even though, looking at the official rabbinate today, one would not know it. The Rabbinate's current attitude toward conversions constitutes a complete reversal of the halakhic decisions of such eminent chief rabbis of the past as Abraham Isaac Kook, Ben-Zion Uziel and Shlomo Goren, all of whom had a much more realistic and positive attitude toward conversion. Certainly, the time has come for the government of Israel, which continues to fight tooth and nail in the courts with no justification to avoid full recognition of the actions of Masorti and Reform rabbinical courts here, to relinquish its foolish, futile and anti-democratic stance.
Yet none of this goes far enough. None of these suggestions are really sufficient to solve the problems of conversion, in particular, and of religious life in Israel, in general. As long as an official rabbinate continues to function as part of the political structure of the government of Israel, with monopolistic powers in so many realms, including marriage and divorce, these problems will continue to plague us.
Those who really care about the future of Judaism in the Jewish state - and this should certainly include the religious- Zionists - should be at the forefront of a battle to separate these religious powers from the state and to privatize the rabbinate, permitting Jews to freely chose their own rabbinical authorities or none. Regarding marriage, for example, the state should set up a system of civil partnerships entered into legally by those it considers eligible, with ensuing rights, even as the religious ceremony remains within the realm of an individual couple, depending on their religious affiliation.
We do not need a total separation of religion and state - this being a Jewish state, that would be all but impossible. What I am proposing is a system by which the state gives help and support to religious institutions but does not dictate their policies, nor does it grant monopolistic rights to any one clerical group. The state is a secular institution and should step back from dictating religious affairs. This is a development that has occurred in every modern Western country, and it is long overdue in Israel, which remains the only country in the free world in which Jews are not free to make their own choices concerning their religious affairs, and in which a rabbinate is empowered to make such decisions against the free will of the inhabitants.
There are three principal serious problems with which the government-sponsored Haredi rabbinate has failed to deal properly: the case of agunot (women who cannot obtain a divorce), shmita (the rabbinate refused to implement Rabbi Kook's method that made it possible to continue using the produce of the Land of Israel in the current agricultural sabbatical year), and now giyur (conversion). All of these have halakhic solutions that the current rabbinate refuses to adopt. This in itself should be sufficient to make us realize that the existence of a state-sponsored Chief Rabbinate is an anachronism Israel can no longer afford. We need freedom of religion here so that individual rights will no longer be trampled and, most of all, so that religion can flourish in Israel.
Rabbi Reuven Hammer is the head of the Rabbinical Court of the Israeli Masorti (Conservative) Movement and a former president of the movement's International Rabbinical Assembly.
Haaretz 20/6/2008
At last the problems of conversion in Israel have begun to receive the attention and press coverage they deserve. Not since the Hanaton conversions in 1995, when our Masorti (Conservative) rabbinical court converted adopted children that the Rabbinate had refused to convert because their adoptive parents were not Orthodox, has so much publicity and public discussion been focused on the way in which Israel's official rabbinical establishment treats potential and actual converts. That earlier crisis led to the formation of the Neeman Commission, which ended its work without even issuing a report - because of the opposition of the Chief Rabbinate to any cooperation with other groups. But it also resulted in a 2002 Supreme Court decision requiring the state to register Masorti converts in Israel as Jews. That was a step forward, but no more than that. It took the high beit din's disgraceful treatment of Rabbi Chaim Druckman earlier this spring, and the retroactive voiding of thousands of his conversions, regardless of the consequences for the converts, their partners and their children, to once again arouse public concern about a problem that has been with us for years.
I am hardly the first to respond to the decision of the Rabbinate's highest court not to recognize conversions carried out by the state-appointed conversion administration headed by Druckman, and with the exception of the occasional ultra-Orthodox writer, all have been critical of the Rabbinate's actions. Depending on each individual writer's religious orientation, there have been calls for the replacement of the court's current judges, all of whom are Haredim, by more moderate religious-Zionist rabbis; for the Israeli Supreme Court to overturn the decisions of the rabbinical court; for the state to fully recognize conversions performed by Masorti and Reform rabbis in Israel; and for the creation of secular conversion, so that non-Jews can join the Jewish people without undergoing any religious process whatsoever.
Many of these suggestions are valuable. It would certainly be a step forward if Haredi rabbis of the Rabbinate and its high court were replaced by Zionist ones. This is, after all, a Zionist state, even though, looking at the official rabbinate today, one would not know it. The Rabbinate's current attitude toward conversions constitutes a complete reversal of the halakhic decisions of such eminent chief rabbis of the past as Abraham Isaac Kook, Ben-Zion Uziel and Shlomo Goren, all of whom had a much more realistic and positive attitude toward conversion. Certainly, the time has come for the government of Israel, which continues to fight tooth and nail in the courts with no justification to avoid full recognition of the actions of Masorti and Reform rabbinical courts here, to relinquish its foolish, futile and anti-democratic stance.
Yet none of this goes far enough. None of these suggestions are really sufficient to solve the problems of conversion, in particular, and of religious life in Israel, in general. As long as an official rabbinate continues to function as part of the political structure of the government of Israel, with monopolistic powers in so many realms, including marriage and divorce, these problems will continue to plague us.
Those who really care about the future of Judaism in the Jewish state - and this should certainly include the religious- Zionists - should be at the forefront of a battle to separate these religious powers from the state and to privatize the rabbinate, permitting Jews to freely chose their own rabbinical authorities or none. Regarding marriage, for example, the state should set up a system of civil partnerships entered into legally by those it considers eligible, with ensuing rights, even as the religious ceremony remains within the realm of an individual couple, depending on their religious affiliation.
We do not need a total separation of religion and state - this being a Jewish state, that would be all but impossible. What I am proposing is a system by which the state gives help and support to religious institutions but does not dictate their policies, nor does it grant monopolistic rights to any one clerical group. The state is a secular institution and should step back from dictating religious affairs. This is a development that has occurred in every modern Western country, and it is long overdue in Israel, which remains the only country in the free world in which Jews are not free to make their own choices concerning their religious affairs, and in which a rabbinate is empowered to make such decisions against the free will of the inhabitants.
There are three principal serious problems with which the government-sponsored Haredi rabbinate has failed to deal properly: the case of agunot (women who cannot obtain a divorce), shmita (the rabbinate refused to implement Rabbi Kook's method that made it possible to continue using the produce of the Land of Israel in the current agricultural sabbatical year), and now giyur (conversion). All of these have halakhic solutions that the current rabbinate refuses to adopt. This in itself should be sufficient to make us realize that the existence of a state-sponsored Chief Rabbinate is an anachronism Israel can no longer afford. We need freedom of religion here so that individual rights will no longer be trampled and, most of all, so that religion can flourish in Israel.
Rabbi Reuven Hammer is the head of the Rabbinical Court of the Israeli Masorti (Conservative) Movement and a former president of the movement's International Rabbinical Assembly.
Libellés :
jewish-immigration,
judaism,
zionism
jeudi 19 juin 2008
Four police officers injured in clashes with West Bank settlers
Haaretz Last update - 15:10 19/06/2008
By Nadav Shragai, Haaretz Correspondent
Four Border Police officers were wounded on Thursday in clashes with settlers, which erupted when security forces came to two illegal outposts near the West Bank settlement of Yitzhar in order to post evacuation orders and to demolish one caravan. Settlers said that 11 of the Yitzhar residents were also wounded, and that one lost consciousness. Several settlers were reportedly arrested after they locked police officers inside Yitzhar following the demolition of a caravan at the nearby illegal outpost of Havat Shaked.
In addition to closing the settlement's gate, the Yitzhar residents also punctured the wheels of the police officers' cars in order to prevent their exit. A Border Police officer taking part in the operation refused orders to assist in the demolition of the caravan, and was arrested by his fellow officers. The officer, an ultra-Orthodox Chabad Hassid, broke down in tears and refused the order after reported pressure from the settlers to do so.
Reffering to the Gaza Strip cease-fire deal that Israel struck with Hamas, Yigal Amitai, a Yitzhar spokesman, said that "only those who make a deal with terrorists in the south and abandon Gilad Shalit and the residents of Sderot have the strength and the gall to fight residents of Samaria." Samaria is the biblical name for the northern West Bank. Amitai also said that Havat Shaked had already been evacuated four times.
On Wednesday, Deputy Defense Minister Matan Vilnai told MK Uri Ariel, the faction head of National Union-National Religious Party, that the Israel Defense Forces and police intend to demolish six caravans this week in the illegal outpost of Bracha A., which is roughly 700 meters from Yitzhar. Vilnai defended the legality of the move, saying, "All of the issues on the matter [of the outpost] have been discussed several times in legal proceedings and therefore the state is determined to demolish it." MK Ariel called Vilnai's statement "shameful," and said that he and his colleagues would exercise their right to civil disobedience in the face of every planned demolition.
By Nadav Shragai, Haaretz Correspondent
Four Border Police officers were wounded on Thursday in clashes with settlers, which erupted when security forces came to two illegal outposts near the West Bank settlement of Yitzhar in order to post evacuation orders and to demolish one caravan. Settlers said that 11 of the Yitzhar residents were also wounded, and that one lost consciousness. Several settlers were reportedly arrested after they locked police officers inside Yitzhar following the demolition of a caravan at the nearby illegal outpost of Havat Shaked.
In addition to closing the settlement's gate, the Yitzhar residents also punctured the wheels of the police officers' cars in order to prevent their exit. A Border Police officer taking part in the operation refused orders to assist in the demolition of the caravan, and was arrested by his fellow officers. The officer, an ultra-Orthodox Chabad Hassid, broke down in tears and refused the order after reported pressure from the settlers to do so.
Reffering to the Gaza Strip cease-fire deal that Israel struck with Hamas, Yigal Amitai, a Yitzhar spokesman, said that "only those who make a deal with terrorists in the south and abandon Gilad Shalit and the residents of Sderot have the strength and the gall to fight residents of Samaria." Samaria is the biblical name for the northern West Bank. Amitai also said that Havat Shaked had already been evacuated four times.
On Wednesday, Deputy Defense Minister Matan Vilnai told MK Uri Ariel, the faction head of National Union-National Religious Party, that the Israel Defense Forces and police intend to demolish six caravans this week in the illegal outpost of Bracha A., which is roughly 700 meters from Yitzhar. Vilnai defended the legality of the move, saying, "All of the issues on the matter [of the outpost] have been discussed several times in legal proceedings and therefore the state is determined to demolish it." MK Ariel called Vilnai's statement "shameful," and said that he and his colleagues would exercise their right to civil disobedience in the face of every planned demolition.
Secular MKs skip debate on rabbinical courts
Jun. 19, 2008
Dan Izenberg , THE JERUSALEM POST
Except for the chairwoman, Amira Dotan, not a single secular MK on the Knesset Law Committee attended a meeting held Thursday to discuss the structure and the functioning of the rabbinical courts.
Out of 17 MKs on the committee, the only ones who attended were Dotan (Kadima), Zeev Elkin (Kadima), Otniel Schneller (Kadima), Menahem Ben-Sasson (Kadima), Avraham Michaeli (Shas), Nissim Ze'ev (Shas) and Moshe Gafni (United Torah Judaism.)
Thursday's meeting was one of a series of discussions meant to provide a comprehensive assessment of the operation of the rabbinical courts, its problems and how to solve them. The decision to review the rabbinical courts was sparked, in part, by the latest State Comptroller's Report, which highlighted several problems.
Dotan, who said she was determined to conduct the meetings in a businesslike and quiet way, unlike most Knesset meetings, said her goal was to clarify the rabbinical court procedures so that the court's clients, secular as well as religious, would be able to understand what was going on and what they had to do.
The committee devoted Thursday's meeting to the problem of case files that lay dormant in the secretariat of the law courts for months at a time.
Rabbi Eli Ben-Dahan, the director-general of the rabbinical courts administration, told the committee that many of these files were divorce files. If a dayan rules that the husband must give his wife a divorce, it is up to the couple to open a divorce file. If, after 30 days, the husband refuses to cooperate, the woman may open a file demanding that sanctions be taken against the husband.
If there is no activity in the file for six months, the case will be brought back to the dayanim who will make contact with the husband and wife to see whether or not they want to proceed. If they still do nothing after two more weeks, the file will automatically be closed.
According to representatives of women's organizations who attended the meeting, the procedure described by Ben-Dahan was in violation of the law. Batya Cahana-Dror, the legal adviser for the women's organization Mavoi Satum (Dead End), told the committee that a law passed in 1995 obliged the court to take the initiative after 30 days and see to it that a decision ordering the husband to grant a divorce was implemented. Since according to halacha, a divorce can only take place when a man gives the divorce decree to the woman and she accepts it, the court cannot grant the divorce in place of the husband. But it can apply one of several quite harsh legal sanctions, including jail, denial of a professional license, denial of a driver's license, and denial of the right to travel abroad to pressure the husband into doing so.
Ben-Dahan and the legal adviser of the rabbinical courts administration, Shimon Ya'acobi, maintained that the dayanim do not want to speed up the process because they hope that in the meantime the couple will make up and drop the proceedings.
But according to Cahana-Dror, often the woman is too frightened or demoralized to ask for sanctions and is not at all thinking of making up with her husband. In these circumstances, by taking the initiative, the court helps the woman by applying sanctions against the recalcitrant husband.
Dan Izenberg , THE JERUSALEM POST
Except for the chairwoman, Amira Dotan, not a single secular MK on the Knesset Law Committee attended a meeting held Thursday to discuss the structure and the functioning of the rabbinical courts.
Out of 17 MKs on the committee, the only ones who attended were Dotan (Kadima), Zeev Elkin (Kadima), Otniel Schneller (Kadima), Menahem Ben-Sasson (Kadima), Avraham Michaeli (Shas), Nissim Ze'ev (Shas) and Moshe Gafni (United Torah Judaism.)
Thursday's meeting was one of a series of discussions meant to provide a comprehensive assessment of the operation of the rabbinical courts, its problems and how to solve them. The decision to review the rabbinical courts was sparked, in part, by the latest State Comptroller's Report, which highlighted several problems.
Dotan, who said she was determined to conduct the meetings in a businesslike and quiet way, unlike most Knesset meetings, said her goal was to clarify the rabbinical court procedures so that the court's clients, secular as well as religious, would be able to understand what was going on and what they had to do.
The committee devoted Thursday's meeting to the problem of case files that lay dormant in the secretariat of the law courts for months at a time.
Rabbi Eli Ben-Dahan, the director-general of the rabbinical courts administration, told the committee that many of these files were divorce files. If a dayan rules that the husband must give his wife a divorce, it is up to the couple to open a divorce file. If, after 30 days, the husband refuses to cooperate, the woman may open a file demanding that sanctions be taken against the husband.
If there is no activity in the file for six months, the case will be brought back to the dayanim who will make contact with the husband and wife to see whether or not they want to proceed. If they still do nothing after two more weeks, the file will automatically be closed.
According to representatives of women's organizations who attended the meeting, the procedure described by Ben-Dahan was in violation of the law. Batya Cahana-Dror, the legal adviser for the women's organization Mavoi Satum (Dead End), told the committee that a law passed in 1995 obliged the court to take the initiative after 30 days and see to it that a decision ordering the husband to grant a divorce was implemented. Since according to halacha, a divorce can only take place when a man gives the divorce decree to the woman and she accepts it, the court cannot grant the divorce in place of the husband. But it can apply one of several quite harsh legal sanctions, including jail, denial of a professional license, denial of a driver's license, and denial of the right to travel abroad to pressure the husband into doing so.
Ben-Dahan and the legal adviser of the rabbinical courts administration, Shimon Ya'acobi, maintained that the dayanim do not want to speed up the process because they hope that in the meantime the couple will make up and drop the proceedings.
But according to Cahana-Dror, often the woman is too frightened or demoralized to ask for sanctions and is not at all thinking of making up with her husband. In these circumstances, by taking the initiative, the court helps the woman by applying sanctions against the recalcitrant husband.
mardi 17 juin 2008
B'Tselem cameras pay off for victims of settler attacks
B'Tselem cameras pay off for victims of settler attacks
By Yuval Azoulay
Haaretz Last update - 13:38 17/06/2008
Three months ago, the B'Tselem human rights organization gave Muna al-Nawaja a video camera. Nawaja, 24, lives near the Israeli settlement of Sussya, in the southern West Bank. Between caring for her young son and tending the family's sheep, she learned to use the camera, fell in love with it and now carries it with her everywhere. But its "baptism of fire" occurred last week, on Sunday afternoon. Most Israelis were busy preparing for the Shavuot holiday. But some had a different priority: savagely beating Nawaja's relatives. She managed to capture a few seconds of the beating - in which her 57-year-old aunt was severely injured, and two uncles, age 60 and 33 were hurt - on film. But she never dreamed that it would prove to be the main, and possibly only, evidence available to the police investigating the assault. "There have been previous incidents in this area in which Palestinians were beaten; that is why they gave me a camera," she explained two days ago.
A few seconds before the attack occurred, Nawaja saw four masked men, some carrying clubs, approaching her relatives, who were tending the family flock. They were clearly not dropping by for coffee, so she aimed her camera at them. "I saw them coming from the direction of a Jewish settlement," she said. The men began beating her relatives, but the victims' screams brought no succor. "So at that point, I stopped filming and ran to summon help," she recalled. But by the time the police arrived, the assailants had fled.
B'Tselem, which used to make do with collecting oral testimony from Palestinians about alleged crimes against them, concluded last year that more graphic documentation was needed, on the theory that a picture is worth 1,000 words. "From our past experience, in many cases a Palestinian's word is given less weight than that of a soldier, a policeman or a settler," explained Oren Yakobovich, who heads the organization's video distribution project.
He said a large American Jewish organization, whose members visited Hebron and were shocked, donated a substantial sum of money to purchase the cameras. As part of its "Shooting Back" project, B'Tselem has distributed about 100 cameras to Palestinians throughout the West Bank over the last year. Of these, several dozen were handed out in the Hebron area, where friction between Palestinians and Israelis is routine.
Even in its pilot stage, about 18 months ago, the project proved its worth, when Rajah Abu Aisha of Hebron videotaped his Jewish neighbor, Yifat Alkobi, verbally assaulting his wife, including calling her a slut. A soldier was nearby, but did nothing. Since the "Shooting Back" project was launched, Palestinians have filed 15 complaints of assault or other rights violations, backed by video documentation, with the police and army.
"The army and the police welcome this," said Yakobovich. "They have documentation of the incidents, and that makes the investigation much shorter and quicker." He said the free cameras have also proved popular among the Palestinians. "There are people who call me and request a camera, because they want to feel protected. And undoubtedly, when they carry a camera, they suffer less violence, because a camera is a deterrent. There are even some who go around with a broken camera, just so that people won't come near them."
Nasser al-Nawaja, who distributes the cameras to Hebron-area Palestinians on B'Tselem's behalf, concurred. "Now, they feel that they are safer and better protected," he said. "That is our response. It is better than stones or aggressive weapons. We simply will film what happens here and show it to all of Israel, which doesn't really know what goes on in the territories."
By Yuval Azoulay
Haaretz Last update - 13:38 17/06/2008
Three months ago, the B'Tselem human rights organization gave Muna al-Nawaja a video camera. Nawaja, 24, lives near the Israeli settlement of Sussya, in the southern West Bank. Between caring for her young son and tending the family's sheep, she learned to use the camera, fell in love with it and now carries it with her everywhere. But its "baptism of fire" occurred last week, on Sunday afternoon. Most Israelis were busy preparing for the Shavuot holiday. But some had a different priority: savagely beating Nawaja's relatives. She managed to capture a few seconds of the beating - in which her 57-year-old aunt was severely injured, and two uncles, age 60 and 33 were hurt - on film. But she never dreamed that it would prove to be the main, and possibly only, evidence available to the police investigating the assault. "There have been previous incidents in this area in which Palestinians were beaten; that is why they gave me a camera," she explained two days ago.
A few seconds before the attack occurred, Nawaja saw four masked men, some carrying clubs, approaching her relatives, who were tending the family flock. They were clearly not dropping by for coffee, so she aimed her camera at them. "I saw them coming from the direction of a Jewish settlement," she said. The men began beating her relatives, but the victims' screams brought no succor. "So at that point, I stopped filming and ran to summon help," she recalled. But by the time the police arrived, the assailants had fled.
B'Tselem, which used to make do with collecting oral testimony from Palestinians about alleged crimes against them, concluded last year that more graphic documentation was needed, on the theory that a picture is worth 1,000 words. "From our past experience, in many cases a Palestinian's word is given less weight than that of a soldier, a policeman or a settler," explained Oren Yakobovich, who heads the organization's video distribution project.
He said a large American Jewish organization, whose members visited Hebron and were shocked, donated a substantial sum of money to purchase the cameras. As part of its "Shooting Back" project, B'Tselem has distributed about 100 cameras to Palestinians throughout the West Bank over the last year. Of these, several dozen were handed out in the Hebron area, where friction between Palestinians and Israelis is routine.
Even in its pilot stage, about 18 months ago, the project proved its worth, when Rajah Abu Aisha of Hebron videotaped his Jewish neighbor, Yifat Alkobi, verbally assaulting his wife, including calling her a slut. A soldier was nearby, but did nothing. Since the "Shooting Back" project was launched, Palestinians have filed 15 complaints of assault or other rights violations, backed by video documentation, with the police and army.
"The army and the police welcome this," said Yakobovich. "They have documentation of the incidents, and that makes the investigation much shorter and quicker." He said the free cameras have also proved popular among the Palestinians. "There are people who call me and request a camera, because they want to feel protected. And undoubtedly, when they carry a camera, they suffer less violence, because a camera is a deterrent. There are even some who go around with a broken camera, just so that people won't come near them."
Nasser al-Nawaja, who distributes the cameras to Hebron-area Palestinians on B'Tselem's behalf, concurred. "Now, they feel that they are safer and better protected," he said. "That is our response. It is better than stones or aggressive weapons. We simply will film what happens here and show it to all of Israel, which doesn't really know what goes on in the territories."
Libellés :
occupied-territories,
violence,
war crimes
mardi 3 juin 2008
Settlers rebuild Hebron outpost after IDF razes it for 32nd time
Haaretz Last update - 13:50 03/06/2008
By Haaretz Service
Kiryat Arba settlers rushed overnight to rebuild the synagogue marking Hazon David, an illegal outpost near Hebron, soon after the Israel Defense Forces and its Civil Administration arm destroyed the structure late on Monday. The outpost, built along the "worshipper's path," which connects Hebron to the settlement of Kiryat Arba, has been destroyed and rebuilt at least 32 times. The synagogue was originally constructed inside a tent and dedicated to the memory of David Cohen and Hezi Mualem, who were killed seven years ago in terrorist attacks next to Kiryat Arba.
In contrast to violent confrontations between settlers and the army at outposts like Havat Gilad, Mitzpe Yitzhar and Amona, IDF moves to raze Hazon David have been generally peaceable.
By Haaretz Service
Kiryat Arba settlers rushed overnight to rebuild the synagogue marking Hazon David, an illegal outpost near Hebron, soon after the Israel Defense Forces and its Civil Administration arm destroyed the structure late on Monday. The outpost, built along the "worshipper's path," which connects Hebron to the settlement of Kiryat Arba, has been destroyed and rebuilt at least 32 times. The synagogue was originally constructed inside a tent and dedicated to the memory of David Cohen and Hezi Mualem, who were killed seven years ago in terrorist attacks next to Kiryat Arba.
In contrast to violent confrontations between settlers and the army at outposts like Havat Gilad, Mitzpe Yitzhar and Amona, IDF moves to raze Hazon David have been generally peaceable.
jeudi 29 mai 2008
Haredi autopsy protest turns violent
Haredi autopsy protest turns violent
Ultra-Orthodox Jews riot in capital: Throw stones at police, burn garbage cans in protest of autopsy to be performed on body of 25-year old man killed in car accident on Monday
Neta Sela
Yedioth Ahranoth Published: 05.29.08, 18:27
Ultra-Orthodox Jews rallied on Thursday afternoon at Jerusalem's Bar Ilan Street and in different areas of the Meah Shearim and Geula neighborhoods, burning garbage cans and throwing stones at police officers who arrived at the scene.
The demonstrators were protesting the decision to allow an autopsy on the body of David Willinger, who was killed in a car accident on Highway 6 on Monday.
When police arrived at the scene of the rally in order to put a stop to the burning of garbage cans, the protesters began to throw stones and bottles at the officers. No injuries were reported, but the stone-throwers escaped.
Many streets in Jerusalem were blocked because of the incident. On Wednesday a similar protest was staged, also due to the autopsy.
Earlier the Magistrate's Court in Nazareth decided to approve the appeal filed by police to perform an autopsy on Willinger's body, but delayed the procedure in order to give the family time to appeal to the High Court of Justice.
Twenty-five-year-old David Willinger was on his way north from Ramat Gan when his car collided with a truck. Police requested the autopsy in order to investigate the possibility that he died of cardiac arrest just before the accident.
The traffic department of Northern District Police stated that they respected the family's feelings on the issue, but an autopsy is required in order to establish the extent of the truck-driver's guilt.
Efrat Weiss contributed to this report
Ultra-Orthodox Jews riot in capital: Throw stones at police, burn garbage cans in protest of autopsy to be performed on body of 25-year old man killed in car accident on Monday
Neta Sela
Yedioth Ahranoth Published: 05.29.08, 18:27
Ultra-Orthodox Jews rallied on Thursday afternoon at Jerusalem's Bar Ilan Street and in different areas of the Meah Shearim and Geula neighborhoods, burning garbage cans and throwing stones at police officers who arrived at the scene.
The demonstrators were protesting the decision to allow an autopsy on the body of David Willinger, who was killed in a car accident on Highway 6 on Monday.
When police arrived at the scene of the rally in order to put a stop to the burning of garbage cans, the protesters began to throw stones and bottles at the officers. No injuries were reported, but the stone-throwers escaped.
Many streets in Jerusalem were blocked because of the incident. On Wednesday a similar protest was staged, also due to the autopsy.
Earlier the Magistrate's Court in Nazareth decided to approve the appeal filed by police to perform an autopsy on Willinger's body, but delayed the procedure in order to give the family time to appeal to the High Court of Justice.
Twenty-five-year-old David Willinger was on his way north from Ramat Gan when his car collided with a truck. Police requested the autopsy in order to investigate the possibility that he died of cardiac arrest just before the accident.
The traffic department of Northern District Police stated that they respected the family's feelings on the issue, but an autopsy is required in order to establish the extent of the truck-driver's guilt.
Efrat Weiss contributed to this report
Inscription à :
Articles (Atom)